NYC Renting Guide

How do you choose a neighborhood and commute when renting in NYC?

Quick answer

In NYC, start with the commute, then look at amenities and your late-night route. A good first pass is to filter for Roosevelt Island, Upper West/Upper East, LIC, Astoria, Forest Hills, Downtown Brooklyn, and in NJ, Newport / Downtown Jersey City.

Talk to Livins

Judging area and commute

1. NYC

These areas work well as a first-pass filter. You still need to come down to the specific building, subway entrance, and late-night route.

Roosevelt Island: quiet, good for Cornell Tech and anyone who wants a settled feel.
Upper West: good for Columbia and anyone active on the Upper West Side.
Upper East / Yorkville: mature amenities, usually a higher budget.
LIC waterfront: lots of buildings, convenient to Midtown, NYU, and Queens.
Astoria / Steinway: a balanced mix of rent, convenience, and commute.
Forest Hills: more residential, good if you can accept a longer commute.
Downtown Brooklyn / Fort Greene: good for NYU Tandon and Lower Manhattan commutes.
Greenpoint: lots of character, but confirm the G train and transfer cost.

Annotated map of common NYC-area rental neighborhoods showing commute, amenities, and community character — When picking an area, look at commute, amenities, distance to school, and neighborhood feel together — not just price.

Guide to reading crime data on the NYC Crime Map — You can use the NYC Crime Map to see how crime is distributed by block: darker colors and larger blue circles generally mean more incidents. Midtown can look average largely because of transit hubs and tourist density; Midtown East usually feels better in person.

2. New Jersey

When considering New Jersey, look at PATH / ferry / bus, your late-night route home, and the immediate block together.

Newport / Downtown Jersey City: clear PATH access, a good first NJ pick.
Weehawken / Port Imperial: lots of waterfront buildings — focus on ferry / bus frequency.
Fort Lee: good if you do not rely heavily on PATH and can accept a bus or driving.
Secaucus: more of a budget-and-space option.
Journal Square: budget-friendly, but check the specific building and late-night route.
Harrison / Bayonne / Newark: worth considering, but new students should not pick them on low rent alone.

Reference chart of studio and shared rents across common NYC-area rental neighborhoods — Budgets per area shift with the building, layout, and season — for reference only.

3. Other

Harlem / Washington Heights / Inwood: Columbia or CUNY students may look here; blocks vary a lot.
Bed-Stuy / Crown Heights: value and new buildings, but block-by-block differences are clear.
Beyond Journal Square, Harrison, Bayonne, Newark: worth checking on budget, but verify the late-night route home.

4. Commute

Check routes separately for the morning rush, the evening, and weekends.
Look at the walking route from your building door to the subway/PATH, not the straight-line distance.
For NYU, look at East Village, Downtown Brooklyn, LIC, Jersey City.
For Columbia, look at Morningside Heights, Upper West, Harlem, Washington Heights.
For Jersey City or Hoboken, factor in PATH delays and late-night frequency.

Watch out for

Use Google Maps to check morning-rush, evening, and weekend routes.
Confirm the actual walking time from your building door to the subway, PATH, ferry, or bus — not the straight-line map distance.
Check whether grocery, pharmacy, laundry, dining, and package pickup are convenient.
Ask students at your school where they live, and cross-check reviews across different platforms.
If you come home late often, verify the safety of the route with street view and an in-person or video walkthrough.

Next step

If you have more questions about renting in NYC, Livins.ai offers free rental guidance and listing recommendations to help you move in with confidence.

Talk to Livins

Questions

Is living in LIC good for NYU?: It can be, but it depends on the specific subway line and where your classes are.
Do I have to live right next to Columbia?: Not necessarily, but living closer early on lowers the adjustment cost for new students.
Is Jersey City worth considering?: It can be when budget matters, but work out the PATH commute and your late-night route home.
For Manhattan schools like Parsons, The New School, SVA, FIT, Baruch, or Pace, how do I choose an area?: First confirm which part of Manhattan the main campus is in, then filter by subway line. For Lower/Midtown schools you can usually consider East Village, Gramercy/Kips Bay, Chelsea, Hell’s Kitchen, LIC, Downtown Brooklyn, or Jersey City — but with lots of evening classes, prioritize places with a simple late-night route.
Where should I live for Pratt, NYU Tandon, or a Brooklyn campus?: Look at Downtown Brooklyn, Fort Greene, Clinton Hill, the edges of Gowanus/Park Slope, and LIC. Brooklyn blocks differ a lot — check the route from the subway station to your door.
For Stevens, Rutgers Newark, or a New Jersey school, does it make sense to live in NYC?: Not necessarily. Stevens students more often look at Hoboken, Newport, Downtown Jersey City; for Rutgers Newark, focus on the area around the Newark campus and NJ Transit/PATH routes. Unless you go to Manhattan often, there is no need to sacrifice commute and safety just to "live in NYC."
Where should I live to study at Cornell Tech in NYC?: Cornell’s main campus is in Ithaca, but Cornell Tech is on Roosevelt Island. Cornell Tech students can prioritize Roosevelt Island, the LIC waterfront, Upper East / Yorkville, and Midtown East, and consider Astoria or other parts of Queens on budget; the key is confirming the F train, tram, ferry, or bus to Roosevelt Island is reliable.
What if my school has multiple campuses or classes spread across locations?: Do not pick an area just by the school name. Lay out a week of your class schedule, choose a route that is reliable to the most class locations, and confirm how you get home after evening classes.

Sources

Last updated 2026-05-04.